ThiefCopy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[RE5: Public Assembly]

Fantastic

Really enjoyed this, the whole racism controversy forced Capcom to add in in White and Asian zombies, which is stupid, if you demand a game have Whites and Asians in a game set in Africa, then YOU are the racist.

That was my little rant there, onto the review.

I enjoyed the way you subtitled this, but I was somewhat lost in the beginning, the whole magic trick thing threw me, but the rest was gold. I find it very unlikely anyone could be actually offended by this animation. It is quite mild, but it helps to put a disclaimer in your authors comments anyway I suppose.

The graphics and style of this were great, somewhat reminiscent of some Johnny Utah animations, I like it.

The sound is great, "Rina-Chan" seems to be getting a lot of work lately, the voices of Chris and Sheva were well done.

The story was well, the same as the demo.

The dialogue, or better yet the subtitles were quite funny, and well written. The last "all look alike" joke is so obvious, but funny nonetheless.

Overall I liked this one, nice to see a RE5 flash, game looks great too. Congrats on front page!

[The Assumption Song]

Well it is all about the song huh?

The animation has a certain undeniable charm to it, but the whole point of this is the song, somewhat cliche, but entertaining nonetheless. And just as it was starting to get dull, the ending made me laugh more than the rest of the song.

The whole thing is that this is not your own song, so to give this a perfect ten would be difficult for me. Still, you used quite a bit of creativity with the suggestive drawings turning into something innocent.

Overall enjoyable, great song, bad drawings in a good way (if that makes sense) and a funny ending. Good work!

[Unnnforgotten Realms 7]

I am very, very conflicted

This is an odd case, at first, I thought you were being an asshole for no reason, then I went and saw the response he left you on your review, although you did somewhat dwell on the "whatever her name is" 's voice acting, you still had a point, not only that, but it was a respectful and well written review, I would love to get more of those in fact, and yet, he ended it by saying he hopes you die, along with other swearing and insults, that's not cool at all. I think this animation is bad, but you already know that, it is the POINT you are trying to make.

And this is the problem, the people are getting mad at you because they are fans, like DeathmasterP below me, anyone who uses the word epitome properly I would expect to be intelligent, but he completely ignored your authors comments, in which you explained your disgust with the author.

But one thing to keep in mind, we can all be assholes at some times, some of my responses to reviews of my movies have been quite pissed off as well (typically to someone harassing me, but nonetheless).

Just keep in mind everyone has days where any minor thing can make them flip out, that being said, I am on your side on this one.

I cannot give this a great score because of the fact it isn't very well made or funny, but I do respect your well written considerate reviews, even if people are bastards, try not to dwell on it.

[Left 4 Speed]

Pretty damn good

I really enjoyed this, and considering all the L4D flashes so far have been garbage, this was a welcome surprise.

The graphics were nice, as one user commented, it is almost in an "Awesome" style, which is neither good nor bad, but the simplicity of it ensures that there is no confusion, with more complex drawing, as things can get disorienting and hard to see, but, this is a comedy, so it is to be expected the graphics would be cartoon-y.

The sound was good, I kept expecting the witch to scream and scare the hell out of me after it loaded. Aside from that, I like how you voiced them yourself, aside from a few that sounded like clips from the game(and if not, then good work!). All in all, the sound was good. Often I find that music or SFX can be much to loud and voices to quiet, but it flowed well.

The style is related to the graphics partially, but this cartoon does a good job of capturing the frustrations and humor of the game, even if most of the jokes are quite obvious and something we all thought of when we saw them. That being said, having more of a relate able material is always good, as people can get lost if all you are doing is inside jokes you have with your friends.

Story, is nonexistent, it is a parody after all, not that that's a problem.

Overall I really liked this one, the thing is, I don't really find some things funny, such as the zombie at the beginning, or the smokers disturbing tongue, those kind of "dick joke" like humor just doesn't make me laugh at all, and I feel many parodies are ruined by having them, such as the MGS collab.

Keep up the good work, and congrats on front page

Oney responds:

thanks man!

[Circle n' Square]

Great

I totally agree with chocolatlove, maybe some people haven't noticed who you guys are. I also appreciate it when these great animators come up with some dumb idea that the average person could not make funny at all, and turn it into something great.

Looking forward to your next half baked ideas!

[Pentagon n' Oval]

Great work

I would say this is on par with EgoRaptors, the whole" where's your corners" idea was brilliant, and well executed. Voice work was great, and more varied than the others, this is getting hard to choose which one I like best.......

Congrats on front page as well.